Skip to main content

WISE ASS WEDNESDAY

I Cried to the Same Playlist for a Week Straight , Then I Tried the Trick Music Therapists Swear By

A solitary person sitting beside headphones and a speaker as music carries them from sadness toward hope

The week I let the playlist win

For one full week, I listened to the same sad playlist every day.

Not once a day, either. I mean in the car, while making coffee, while pretending to answer emails, and once while standing in the kitchen staring into the refrigerator like the answer to my problems was hiding behind the leftover pizza.

It was not.

The playlist was full of the usual emotional heavy hitters: songs about regret, missing people, losing time, being generally disappointed in yourself, and wondering whether everybody else received an instruction manual for adulthood that somehow got lost in the mail.

By day three, I knew exactly when each song would hurt.

By day five, I was crying before the lyrics even started. That takes talent, honestly.

This was part of our October series, The Octaves of October, where we’re looking at the way music meets us in real life: during panic, grief, parenting stress, loneliness, depression, and those weird in-between moments when nothing is technically wrong but you still feel like a phone with 2% battery.

Music has always been one of my first emotional tools. Sometimes it helps me name what I’m feeling. Sometimes it gives me permission to feel it. And sometimes, if I’m not careful, I use it like an emotional recliner and refuse to stand up.

That was the problem.

I wasn’t processing anything anymore. I was just marinating in sadness with excellent production quality.

Headphones, a mug, and handwritten playlist cards representing an emotional listening ritual

My original sad playlist

Here’s the playlist I looped for the first week:

  1. “Funeral” , Phoebe Bridgers
  2. “Videotape” , Radiohead
  3. “About Today” , The National
  4. “Skinny Love” , Bon Iver
  5. “Appointments” , Julien Baker
  6. “Holocene” , Bon Iver
  7. “Landslide” , Fleetwood Mac

There is nothing wrong with any of these songs. They are beautiful. They are honest. They have helped me through some rough days.

But when you play the same emotional material over and over, something changes. The song stops being a doorway and starts becoming a room.

And I was living in that room.

The first few listens actually helped. I felt understood. The music said the things I didn’t know how to say without sounding like I was auditioning for a very low-budget indie film.

Then the playlist started making the sadness bigger.

A song can give shape to grief, but it can also keep handing grief the microphone. At some point, I wasn’t listening to understand myself. I was listening because being miserable had become familiar.

Who comes up with these things? Why does the brain sometimes decide that the most comforting place is the exact place that makes us feel worse?

What the iso principle is supposed to do

The experiment I tried next is based on something called the iso principle.

The basic idea is simple: begin with music that matches your current emotional state, then gradually move toward music that represents where you want to go.

Not “you’re sad, so listen to a cheerful song immediately.”

That approach has never worked for me. When I’m depressed and someone says, “Just put on something upbeat,” I want to hand them a clipboard and ask them to document their mistake.

The iso principle starts by meeting the sadness instead of arguing with it. Then, little by little, the music changes. The tempo may get lighter. The lyrics may become less hopeless. The sound may open up. The emotional temperature shifts without demanding that you become a completely different person in the next three minutes.

A 2021 controlled experimental study on the iso principle looked at how different music sequences affected people after sadness was induced. The group that heard sad music first and happier music afterward reported the highest positive affect and emotional valence compared with several other sequences.

That does not mean one playlist cures depression. It does not mean music replaces therapy, medication, community, or professional support. The study involved healthy adults experiencing short-term sadness, not people living with a long-term mental health condition.

Still, the idea made sense to me.

Maybe I didn’t need to yank myself out of sadness. Maybe I needed to walk myself out.

The new playlist progression

For the second part of my experiment, I built a playlist in three sections.

Step one: meet the mood

I started with three of the same songs from the original playlist:

  • “Funeral” , Phoebe Bridgers
  • “About Today” , The National
  • “Appointments” , Julien Baker

These songs still made me sad, but I listened differently this time. I didn’t hit repeat automatically. I sat with what came up.

I asked myself a few basic questions:

  • What am I actually feeling?
  • Is this song helping me release something or helping me avoid something?
  • Am I remembering a specific person or just feeling generally worn out?
  • What would I need if I stopped trying to fix this for ten minutes?

That last question was harder than it should have been.

Step two: create a bridge

Then I moved into songs that were still reflective, but less closed-off:

  • “Holocene” , Bon Iver
  • “Landslide” , Fleetwood Mac
  • “Mystery of Love” , Sufjan Stevens
  • “The Joke” , Brandi Carlile

These songs didn’t suddenly make me happy. That wasn’t the point.

They made room.

The sound felt wider. The lyrics still carried sadness, but they also carried perspective. There was a sense that pain could exist without becoming the entire weather system.

This was the part I had skipped during my first week. I had sad songs and then more sad songs. No bridge. No shift. Just emotional quicksand with a really good bass line.

Step three: move toward lighter

The final section was intentionally more open and hopeful:

  • “Here Comes the Sun” , The Beatles
  • “Dog Days Are Over” , Florence + The Machine
  • “Lovely Day” , Bill Withers
  • “Three Little Birds” , Bob Marley & The Wailers

I know. “Here Comes the Sun” is almost offensively obvious.

But sometimes the obvious thing is obvious because it works.

I didn’t feel transformed when “Here Comes the Sun” played. I did not levitate. No cinematic sunlight burst through the window while a wise old bird nodded at me.

I just noticed that my shoulders had dropped.

I had stopped clenching my jaw.

I was breathing a little deeper.

That counted.

Abstract musical stepping stones moving from deep blue shadow toward warm golden light

The difference between drowning and using music as a stepping stone

The first playlist helped me cry, but then it kept asking me to stay underwater.

The second playlist helped me cry and then gave me something to hold onto.

That distinction mattered.

There are times when we need to hear the sad song. We need the song that says, “Yes, this hurts. No, you’re not the only person who has ever felt this way.” There is comfort in being emotionally recognized.

But recognition is not the same as recovery.

Sometimes I confuse feeling deeply with doing something helpful. I tell myself I’m being honest when I’m actually rehearsing the same pain. I call it reflection when it’s really rumination wearing a nicer jacket.

The new playlist gave me a sequence. It let me start where I was without insisting that I stay there.

That is what changed the experience.

How to try this without overcomplicating it

You don’t need a perfect playlist or a degree in music therapy. You need to pay attention to what the music is doing to you.

Try this:

  1. Name your current mood.
    Sad, angry, numb, restless, panicked, lonely, exhausted. Be specific if you can.

  2. Choose two or three songs that honestly match it.
    Not songs that make the feeling worse on purpose. Songs that make you feel understood.

  3. Add a middle section.
    Choose music that is a little more spacious, steady, or reflective. This is the bridge.

  4. End with two or three songs that carry the mood you want next.
    Calm, hopeful, energized, grounded, or simply less trapped.

  5. Listen without multitasking for at least one song.
    Put the phone down. Take a walk. Sit in your car. Let the song be the thing for a few minutes.

  6. Check in afterward.
    Ask: Do I feel different? Do I feel more connected to myself? Did the music help me move, or did it pull me deeper?

There is no requirement to reach happiness. Sometimes the destination is just “I can wash a dish now” or “I’m not going to send that angry text.”

Those are legitimate victories.

A relaxed person walking along a path while musical notes shift from dark blue to warm amber

Music can meet us without keeping us stuck

I still love my sad playlist. I’m not throwing Phoebe Bridgers into the emotional recycling bin.

But I’m paying more attention now.

When I’m having a rough day, I try not to shame myself for needing the heavy song. I also try not to let the heavy song become the only voice in the room.

That may be the most useful part of this experiment: we don’t have to leap from despair to joy. We can move by inches. We can let one song help us cry, another help us breathe, and another remind us that tomorrow has not been canceled just because today is difficult.

If you’re struggling, music can be one small tool. So can talking to someone, taking a shower, going outside, writing down what’s happening, or reaching out to a mental health professional. If you are in immediate danger or thinking about harming yourself, call or text 988 in the United States and Canada, or contact your local emergency services.

For the rest of us, the next step may be smaller.

Make the playlist.

Let it meet you where you are.

Then give yourself a chance to move.

Maybe not all the way out of the hole. Maybe just one song closer to the edge.

Translate